The Implications of Gender on Diving

Physical factors effecting women.

21 June 2021

By Danel Wentzel

The basic health demands of diving are simple, but a diver's mind and body must be able to safely handle the physical loads of pressurised gases in and out of solution, as well as the inherent demands and dangers of the sea.

When it comes to being fit to dive, gender is the last thing that comes to mind. Age, body build and medical history are all very important factors to consider when diving, but did you know there are physical factors that also affect women.

These differences particular to women is not because of lack of any abilities or understanding, but purely due to the fact that us girls are well, girls. These differences are due to both physical and physiological factors. Some are good, others bad and a couple are based on myth. Let's explore some of these.

Fat Distribution.

Have you ever heard that women are able to tolerate cold conditions better than men? Turns out there's some truth to this. In general, our lean body mass (mass minus that of fat) is less than men, this is because we have a greater natural distribution of fatty tissue underlying our skin.

However, this increased amount of fatty tissue serves as a greater store for nitrogen in our bodies, theoretically increasing our risk to getting the bends over men. But this is nothing to worry about, as the risk of getting the bends is rare providing we follow our diving tables.

All in the legs.

In general, women tend to harnest their lower-body strength more than men, who rely more on their upper-body strength. Studies have found that men on avergae, kick more than women to cover the excact same distance. This more effective kicking style, combined with a smaller lung volume results in a better air-consumption, making us ladies able to stay down for longer and capable of providing more air incase a buddy runs out.

Periods.

Okey, this is one myth I would like to address. YES, you can still dive when you are on your period. Many women refrain from diving as they believe sharks will detect the scent of blood in the water (and yes I do get asked this). With knowing that it is possible to dive, there are still a few things to keep in mind.

Heavy periods can cause problems, especially when they result in iron deficiency. Your body's ability to carry oxygen efficiently is reduced, which might put you at risk of tiring out while swimming into strong currents. Diving with severe stomach cramps can also be potentially dangerous, as it leads to an inability to swim properly on a dive.

So saying you can dive, doesn't mean you always should. My general saying is if any of your symptoms requires medication, the answer is easy - don't dive! ALWAYS make sure to listen to your body.

Diving while on The Pill.

The majority of oral contraceptives contain combined derivatives of the two hormones, oestrogen and progesterone. The basic idea is to stop the cyclic flow of our bodies releasing a viable egg from our ovaries each month. Without ovulation, no fertilisation can occur and mission accomplished. However, there are some side-effects to be aware of.

One such side-effect is the tendency for platelets to clump, leading to abnormal blood clotting, especially around the calf veins where blood flow is slower and more sluggish than anywhere else in the body. Venous nitrogen bubbles that can form after a dive also stimulate platelet aggregation around them, leading to the increased risk of venous thrombosis in female divers on the pill.

If you are diving while on the pill try and take precaution - practise safe diving, take care to avoid excessive bubble loading and ensure you're calf muscles aren't compressed during the dive. You can also sit or lie with your knees extended after a dive to allow easy blood flow from your calves.

The Psychological factor.

In my experience, girls fall within two groups of divers. Most girls are extremely safe and independent divers, always planning and executing their dive plan. They take few risks and are very considerate diving buddies. However, a few girls fall under the 'barbie doll diver' league. They normally request their male buddies to help with every aspect including carrying gear, set up and dive plan. Buddies like this can become a liability, as over time one might forget the basics and when a problem arises are then incapable of providing a safe solution.

In diving, there is no place for sloppiness - both buddies in a team need to be fully independent divers as you have to rely on each other with your life.

Other factors.

Other factors that women should keep in mind before diving in on their next scuba trip include,

  • Pregnancy

  • Breastfeeding

  • Menopause

  • Hysterectomies

I'm choosing to not go into any more detail on these (mainly as I'm not experienced enough to cover these topics). However I am including some useful readings covering these topics.

Pregnancy & Diving

Diving while pregnant

Diving and pregnancy

So to conclude, it is clear that women have a few extra things to keep in mind when planning a dive comparred to their male dive buddies. However, it's because of these extra factors that women tend to be safer and more meticulous divers.

Our bodies are better adapted against the cold, our more effective kicking-style results in a lower air consumption and face it - girls are just fun to have around on a dive!

Whether girls are better divers than men, well I'll leave that up to you to answer.

References:

  • Safe Diving, A medical handbook for scuba divers - by Allan Kayle.